FNX 45

Joined
Sep 8, 2014
Messages
130
Likes
8
Location
Wmass
Feedback: 0 / 0 / 0
Well I picked up a new FNX 45. Grabbed a box of my go to reloads that I use in my 1911 only to find out they are either too light or I have a problem with the gun. [sad2] My guess is the ammo. 200g plated RN loaded on the higher end that I have used forever in my 1911 with out a single issue.. After searching some forums apparently the FNX does not like 185 or 200g bullets when new. they actually suggest +P for break in.[thinking] I will be loading up some 230g this week and trying again this weekend.
 
Probably too light the fn is built like a tank. Probably needs a little umph to break her in. Could always load them sumbitches hot too if you'd prefer
 
Leaving it with the slide locked open a while might help loosen that recoil spring. That and fire a load of +P's thru. I had a pile of .45 Golden Sabers at one point that were pretty hot. Seemed to beat the gun pretty good.
 
You can try loading some up with a hotter powder too. My 230gr loads with CFE is pretty stout. 6.5gr @ 1.250. If you were around Worcester I'd offer you up some. Try Geco ammo as well too. Noticed tonight it says major factor on the box.
 
Leaving it with the slide locked open a while might help loosen that recoil spring.

Just like leaving your magazines loaded does not "loosen" your magazine springs, leaving a slide locked back will not "loosen" a recoil spring....

I have seen 3 FNX 45s choke on reloads, all I would suspect are loaded light. As with any new gun, factory ammo providers a better baseline when new. (I've seen a FNX choke on WWB which is also reguarded as on the lower end of power when the gun was new)
 
Just like leaving your magazines loaded does not "loosen" your magazine springs, leaving a slide locked back will not "loosen" a recoil spring....

I have seen 3 FNX 45s choke on reloads, all I would suspect are loaded light. As with any new gun, factory ammo providers a better baseline when new. (I've seen a FNX choke on WWB which is also reguarded as on the lower end of power when the gun was new)

^^this

run factory ammo first. Remove the ammo issue from equation.
i owned an fnx45 and +P loads were never needed. It ran flawless w any 230gr factory loads.
 
Just like leaving your magazines loaded does not "loosen" your magazine springs, leaving a slide locked back will not "loosen" a recoil spring....

I have seen 3 FNX 45s choke on reloads, all I would suspect are loaded light. As with any new gun, factory ammo providers a better baseline when new. (I've seen a FNX choke on WWB which is also reguarded as on the lower end of power when the gun was new)

Thanks for the replies. I loaded up some hotter 230g and try that. I refuse to go out and buy NEW ammo. Im just stubborn like that. haven't broke in a new gun with factory ammo yet and don't plan too. unless I still have issues with the 230g I loaded up.
 
^^this

run factory ammo first. Remove the ammo issue from equation.
i owned an fnx45 and +P loads were never needed. It ran flawless w any 230gr factory loads.


Remington UMC, WWB and Aquila 230gr FMJ, all ran flawlessly through my FNX45. Have not tried anything else with it yet.
 
Somebody forgot to tell Woolf Gunsprings that leaving mags loaded doesnt fatigue springs:

https://www.gunsprings.com/index.php?page=FAQ#question5




Just like leaving your magazines loaded does not "loosen" your magazine springs, leaving a slide locked back will not "loosen" a recoil spring....

I have seen 3 FNX 45s choke on reloads, all I would suspect are loaded light. As with any new gun, factory ammo providers a better baseline when new. (I've seen a FNX choke on WWB which is also reguarded as on the lower end of power when the gun was new)
 
Somebody forgot to tell Woolf Gunsprings that leaving mags loaded doesnt fatigue springs:

https://www.gunsprings.com/index.php?page=FAQ#question5

Her was an answer provided on a physics site
There are a few things to consider: The phenomenon known as creep, as mentioned above, only affects materials at or above ~0.4x their melting point, in absolute temperature (kelvin). This is unlikely to be an issue in regular service unless your springs are made of something absurd like lead, which actually creeps are room temperature. (I am assuming the temperature increases as a result of firing the weapon are small) Stress-strain cycles, on the other hand, play a major role in spring wear. Ferrous material like iron and most steels exhibit an infinite lifetime under a particular amount of stress amplitude - not the absolute stress, which is generally far less - (the so-called "fatigue limit"). Less ductile materials like aluminum and titanium have a finite cycle life regardless of the stress amplitude; however, parts designed with these materials generally have lifetimes in the millions of cycles and fail by different modes long before the lifetime is reached. So obviously, the life of the spring depends on proper design and materials choice. The spring steel that your gun would most likely use is a moderately-high carbon steel, with potentially nickel, silicon and manganese alloying agents in small quantities. Properly designed, it would last far longer than the other components of the gun that are regularly undergoing thermal stress, diffusion, and much larger fatigue cycles. It's safe to say that storing your mag in a properly designed gun, will not wear out the spring prematurely. However, removing 1 or 2 rounds would increase the odds that you are maintaining the spring stress below the critical fatigue limit. As a footnote, springs in regular circumstances follow Hooke's Law, which states that F=-kx (k being a materials, or "spring" constant and x being displacement). Thus, spring force is linear to displacement. I saw this forum post from an article on the main page, and as a 4th year material engineer student I couldn't resist signing up to answer your question. Hope this helps!

To your original point that locking back a slide on a pistol for a day or two will "loosen" it is beyond a shadow of a doubt 100% false. We can debate semantics on minute percentage reductions a spring may have if kept compressed over a period of 40 or 50 years... if you are using that logic you should probably jack up your car each night to unload the spring tension on any coil springs
 
There is always an element of voodoo involved when people don't understand basic physics. That is about the only way I can explain spring "break-in" and Frog Lube. I rank them very close together in terms of "wtf" value.
 
I understand basic physics we're just arguing the same point. See #6 in the FAQ I posted. A new spring takes a set and then settles into into operating range, which should then be stable.

There is always an element of voodoo involved when people don't understand basic physics. That is about the only way I can explain spring "break-in" and Frog Lube. I rank them very close together in terms of "wtf" value.
 
Last edited:
UPDATE: I loaded up some heavier 230g Plated RN behind 5.8g of HP38. Solved my cycling issues on my new FNX 45. Then I messed with BE86 at 7g and 7.3g(low +P range). The gun really liked that +P stuff. I might load up a few of those for some fun and to break the gun in.
 
UPDATE: I loaded up some heavier 230g Plated RN behind 5.8g of HP38. Solved my cycling issues on my new FNX 45. Then I messed with BE86 at 7g and 7.3g(low +P range). The gun really liked that +P stuff. I might load up a few of those for some fun and to break the gun in.

Glad you got it sorted out... I have to admit, a FNX.45 Tactical is creeping into my "want" list
 
Glad you got it sorted out... I have to admit, a FNX.45 Tactical is creeping into my "want" list

It handled those +P with ease. I want to shoot my buddies M&P45 with the +P just to compare. the FNX is considerably heavier than the M&P.

I'm just trying to find a good plinking load now. HP38 is too dirty with the loads I made up, even t max load.. BE86 was clean but very snappy. Loaded up some Titegroup to try out next weekend
 
It handled those +P with ease. I want to shoot my buddies M&P45 with the +P just to compare. the FNX is considerably heavier than the M&P.

I'm just trying to find a good plinking load now. HP38 is too dirty with the loads I made up, even t max load.. BE86 was clean but very snappy. Loaded up some Titegroup to try out next weekend


I use titegroup for everything pistol, admittedly out of laziness as it meters well and I have a bunch of it
 
I use titegroup for everything pistol, admittedly out of laziness as it meters well and I have a bunch of it

The only thing that bothers me about titegroup is lack of case fill; double charges (and maybe even triple) are possible in a 45 ACP case.

Sent from my XT1575 using Tapatalk
 
Glad you got it sorted out... I have to admit, a FNX.45 Tactical is creeping into my "want" list

had one for about a week. it just felt meh in my hands. i know it's a well built gun and not cheap, but the frame just felt flimsy to me. the slide felt well machined and solid. however the frame material, grip and decocker just didn't feel solid. i have to say for a DA/SA polymer gun, the trigger was excellent. recoil was nonexistent. I can see the appeal of the FNX-45, but compared to an HK45 or G21 I just had no use for it.
 
had one for about a week. it just felt meh in my hands. i know it's a well built gun and not cheap, but the frame just felt flimsy to me. the slide felt well machined and solid. however the frame material, grip and decocker just didn't feel solid. i have to say for a DA/SA polymer gun, the trigger was excellent. recoil was nonexistent. I can see the appeal of the FNX-45, but compared to an HK45 or G21 I just had no use for it.

I honestly hated the way the backstrap felt when I first handled it, reminded me my dads Ruger SR9 (very square feeling and it twisted when I shot it). But in the box they have a rounded one and I asked the store owner to swap it, and I was sold on the rounded edge one. I have big hands though so I could se where this would be an issue.
 
Back
Top Bottom