Ithaca Shotguns - Anyone else have a "thing" for these guns...?

ccm75

NES Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2007
Messages
6,907
Likes
5,101
Location
Worcester County
Feedback: 7 / 0 / 0
I was spending some time in the safe this evening and decided to pull out some of my favorites to wipe them down and clean a couple that I’ve been using. And I got to thinking about how I ended up with so many Ithaca shotguns....You could say I have a “thing” for Ithaca guns.

I grew up in Trumansburg, NY which is just up the lake from Ithaca. When I was a kid everyone I knew had an Ithaca in their house. I went to school with kids whose dads, uncles or grandfathers worked for “the gun company”. I remember the night my father came home with a NIB Deluxe 37 that he bought through my uncles little bait and tackle shop over on Seneca Lake. It was 1970 and I can still remember the long white box and the new beautiful gun that my dad would use to hunt birds and I would learn to shoot with. That gun still hangs in the top pegs of my father’s gun rack.

I grew up hunting with and shooting a hand-me-down Mossie 500 from my uncle and I dreamed of the day that I too would have my own Model 37…..Fast forward about 10-15 years when I was out of the service, single with not much debt and making some money. It seemed like every gun shop I went into had a few nice Ithaca shotguns for me to drool over and eventually I was able to pick one up here and there.

My first nice Ithaca that I was able to buy was a real gem and is still my go to bird gun. I found it at Bob’s in Webster in May of 1991 after I moved to MA for work. It was a NIB 37 Ultralight, 12 ga., mfg. 1984, with beautiful wood. Bob or his dad weren’t in the store that morning so after looking at the gun and realizing I had to have it, I asked the woman if she could work with me on the price and she gave me a nice discount. The next time I went in there I told Bob how much I liked the gun and he said - “That was you! You’re lucky I wasn’t here that day. That was my last new Ithaca made Ithaca and you got a good price on that gun…!” And from there my modest collection grew to multiple Ithaca guns; mostly 37’s. I hunt with most of them but several never leave the safe…

I love a NIB gun from the 70’s or 80’s and hope to find the time to learn more about the earlier trap guns and maybe someday acquire a single barrel trap gun along with a 1911. I have a small collection of catalogs and advertising and need to get back to hunting for those great old catalogs that I poured through as a kid in the 70’s. I’m happy to own two signed copies of Walt Snyder’s books about Ithaca Gun. These are a must read for anyone that has an interest in the history of some great American gun making.

From top to bottom: (Sorry for the lousy pics..)
37-Mag, 20 ga. New Unfired, 1977; short run of 20ga in 3”, with original inspection hang tag and deluxe wood.
37 DS, 26” barrel, shoots like a rifle. Mfg. 1970.
37 FL, 20 ga. VR, Mod. Mfg. 1970, My son’s current bird gun.
37 ULT as mentioned above. 1984 still mint.
37 DS, 20” 12 ga. My current deer gun. Mfg. 1983, with dozens of deer to it's credit.
Model 51, 20ga., 1987, LNIB.
Model 66, 20 ga., 1978
Model 49, .22, 1978
And to left, the red headed step child, a King Ferry 37, 20ga DS/Turkey combo.
photo 1.jpg photo 2.jpg

Thanks for looking and show me your favorite Ithaca!
 
I hunted for 15 yrs in Hecter and on Sundays go to the Firestation for breakfest in Trumansburg. My buddy is from the area and his go to gun is definatly an Ithaca ! Havent been up in about 5 yrs, man what a deer herd they got up there ! we also like our Makers Mark ;) my buddies father had/has a farm in Mecklynburg.
 
Last edited:
Very nice collection. My first and still primary bird gun is a 1942 Model 37 in 12 Gauge. I picked up a sweet little 1969 20 gauge from one of the NES gang a couple of years ago. I'd like to find a Deerslayer to complete the set. I suppose I should find a 16 gauge, too. It's still a good gauge for upland game. I have killed deer with the 12, but don't want to overstress the old timer, so I've been using a Browning A5 and a Remington 870 lately.
 
Nice stuff. This is the only one I have. 1977 M&P in chrome like new in box. This one may end up on the chopping block. It's been sitting in the safe for years.... I just can't bring myself to shoot it.


1404842_10201864309121884_1431443075_o.jpg
 
I grew up on 37's as well. My dad wore out a 16 shooting rabbits over beagles. Then he got a 12 and there is not much for bluing on that one either. When I got married (the first time) He gave me a new 37 (with a lefty safety). That was 12 years ago. Since then, I have a few more but that one he gave me is still the "new one" in the collection and its my "go to" hunting and trap gun.

When I was about 17 I once said to my dad "That thing is beat up you should get a new one.". He said "Are you shitting me, You wish your car ran that good!".
 
Last edited:
Beautiful collection!

I don't have an Ithaca, but do have its cousin, made IN Ithaca in 1927, a Lefever Long Range Field & Trap single-barrel break action in 16ga. Second from the bottom in this picture.

ETA: for those who don't know, Lefever was eventually acquired by Ithaca, so I guess mine is more of a half-sister to yours than it is a cousin.

504b32564f33a2bbbad3967d59b11796_zps047f1438.jpg
 
Last edited:
I like the fact that you can still find a lot of them with US or police property stamps for decent money. I keep saying one day I'm going to get one.
 
My grandfather bought a Model 37 16 gauge Featherlight new in 1947. Still in beautiful shape, It is great to shoot as a left-hander and holds a prominent position in my collection.
 
Nice stuff. This is the only one I have. 1977 M&P in chrome like new in box. This one may end up on the chopping block. It's been sitting in the safe for years.... I just can't bring myself to shoot it.


1404842_10201864309121884_1431443075_o.jpg

That's a beauty! Hang on to it - they don't make them like that any more!!
 

Sad is right. Some of the original machinery went up to King Ferry, NY and then to Sandusky, OH I believe.

The guys in OH make a nice gun and at least the name is still out there.

Can you picture that factory during war time and then later in the post-war economy cranking out all kinds of awesome shotguns..? A true shame - the loss of history and American gun making.
 
Last edited:
My first shotgun, maybe 50 yrs ago was a 37. Eventually I made a SBS out of it and sold it as a NFA sawed off. Looked pretty mean with the 13" bbl and pistol grip. I never shot it much, but it was a fun project. Jack.
 
That's a beauty! Hang on to it - they don't make them like that any more!!

This finish was rare in general in the 37's. These come up from time to time on the auction site and can go for big money. I was looking for a ballpark figure on what it was worth so I put it on GB with a very high hidden reserve. She went all the way up to $1600..... doubt I could get that today, but not bad for a $300 investment. [wink]
 
Last edited:
I have my dads 12 gauge feather weight which he used while I was growing up for pheasant and rabbits. He bought me its twin in 20 gauge when I was 16. I still have both. My dad turned 100 this year and when I get a chance I will check the numbers on it to try and determine the year of manufacture. My guess it was built sometime in the 50's.
The engraving on his is still in great shape. The bluing is worn but no rust or pitting. That shotgun put food on our table when I was growing up.
 
Sad is right. Some of the original machinery went up to King Ferry, NY and then to Sandusky, OH I believe.

The guys in OH make a nice gun and at least the name is still out there.

Can you picture that factory during war time and then later in the post-war economy cranking out all kinds of awesome shotguns..? A true shame - the loss of history and American gun making.

I took another look through those photos....

When I was out of the Army and working in Ithaca I lived with two high school buddies just around the corner from the factory. It was shuttered then and in disrepair. I walked up and down that hill past the big stack and main gate many a time on my way to and from the Falls Tavern (?) at the bottom of the hill. Lot's of water falls and water power along there which I assume is the reason they set up there in the 1800's. If I stood in the street in front of my apartment I could see the main building with the Ithaca Gun lettering on the white façade as well as the big brick stack.

And in the other direction up the hill was the front gate to Cornell Univ. and plenty of coed packed watering holes along the way. Dunbars, Chapter House, The Nines are a few that I can recall. Living on Gun Hill just below College Town was a fun time...but that's for a different thread ...
 
Last edited:
I have an old Ithaca (1948) that I picked up for only $106. It's not a deerslayer, but a 12 gauge featherlight. It needed some TLC but I saw the potential in it and fixed it right up with only $25 in supplies. I wouldn't mind adding an 18" barrel model to the stable, but see a FN SLP as my next shotgun
 
I just picked up a nice 1973 feather light 12 not too long ago. It was in near excellent condition for its age. It was cheap money too for the quality. I also had a feather light 16 but got rid of it for some dumb reason. Still kicking myself in the ass over it.

I've seen some of the new Ithaca's from the Sandusky Ohio, pricey but they make a quality gun in America. Pullman arms has quite a few of them.

The nice part is the Sandusky plant has any parts you need, and barrels too. So if you do find an old girl and need to do some work there are plenty of parts available right online.

- - - Updated - - -

I have my dads 12 gauge feather weight which he used while I was growing up for pheasant and rabbits. He bought me its twin in 20 gauge when I was 16. I still have both. My dad turned 100 this year and when I get a chance I will check the numbers on it to try and determine the year of manufacture. My guess it was built sometime in the 50's.
The engraving on his is still in great shape. The bluing is worn but no rust or pitting. That shotgun put food on our table when I was growing up.

Very easy to check the year off of the Ithaca website, all the numbers are listed.....
 
My first "M37" was actually a Remington Model 17 in 20 ga.; the original JMB designed gun (as doG intended). I'm looking for another if anyone sees one.

KTP usually has three or four M37's on the rack, and every time I go I usually walk around the store for an hour trying to justify why I should buy another. I really want a nice, slick post war model so I can start a collection.

Here's my mid-seventies M37:

 
Last edited:
I have the same one, only it's Parkerized, not chrome. I restored the furniture to the original wood because I didn't like the Choate plastic ware.

As I say, if it was good enough for Malloy and Reed, it's good enough for me! [laugh]

Seriously, they are very reliable shotguns.

Nice stuff. This is the only one I have. 1977 M&P in chrome like new in box. This one may end up on the chopping block. It's been sitting in the safe for years.... I just can't bring myself to shoot it.


1404842_10201864309121884_1431443075_o.jpg
 
This is mine...a 1968 production. The barrel is cut down to 18.5". I re-parkerized it and finished the furniture.


I built this puppy. The slide and most of the small bits are 1943 Ithaca. The frame is a Remsport.
 
Back
Top Bottom