• If you enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for a NES Membership  The benefits pay for the membership many times over.

Memorial day

426wedge

NES Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
2,709
Likes
1,850
Location
western MA
Feedback: 0 / 0 / 0
My brother was lost at Chosin Resorvoir on 2 December 1950. I had contacted a childhood friend of his about 7 years ago. His name was William G Mahar. Bill was able to tell me the events leading up to my brother's death as he was in Korea the at the same time period.

This is a copy of a remembrance entry at the Korean War Project by Mr. Mahar:

"I knew Remi growing up as kids in Westfield, went to his house High St. as I recall, ran into him again in Tokyo PX in the summer of 1950, stayed overnight at my unit in Tokyo on his way back up to Sendai to rejoin the 7th. Division, we had pictures taken together and I gave them to his mother when I returned from Korea in 1952. At the time she was living up near Noble Hospital. Later years talked to his 1st. Sgt. in Heavy Mortar Co up at the Chosin Reservoir. WGM"

I also located another friend of my brother that enlisted on the same day with him in 1948. His name was Gordon Snyder, also a Korean War vet. Gordon happened to be a ceremonial guard at the Agawam Veterans Memorial Cemetery. He contacted me after doing research so he could have a memorial erected at the cemetery for my brother, because it had to be done by family. I had to prove my relationship to the cemetery to get the stone put up, which did happen eventually.

Anyway, here is the letter that Bill Mahar had sent me. I posted this here a while ago, but I will do this every Memorial Day. Bill was in his 80's when he wrote this...

Remi and I used to fish together in the Westfield River over where the railroad bridge crosses from Elm to North Elm St. Met Remi in Tokyo at the snack bar in the PX., he had been down in Eta-jima school command attending a school and when the Korean War started the military closed the school and sent all the students back to their units, Remi was heading back to the 31st. Infantry Regiment, heavy mortar company, 7th. Infantry Division up in Northern Japan, Sendai. He stayed over night at my unit in Tokyo, then left the next day to report in to his unit. During his stay with me we had pictures(portrait) taken and when I got back to Westfield I took a picture of him and gave it to his mother, who at the time lived on W. Silver St. in a house across from Noble Hospital. It probably is around somewhere. My unit got to Korea ahead of his unit and when his unit got to Pusan Harbor on troop ships designated to the invasion of Inchon Harbor. I recall talking to a 7th. MP down on the docks in Pusan and mentioned Remi's unit to him and he pointed out the actual ship that the unit was on. Unfortunately I did not go out to see him as I figured I would see him up the line sometime. Never did. Remi was in the Inchon invasion and later was involved with the Chosin Reservoir operation. Where Remi's Regiment had 4 Chinese Divisions roll over them. If you do any reading and can get the book titled East of The Chosin, author Roy Appleman you might find it interesting. Talked a few years back to Remi's First Sgt(now dead) in Phoenix AZ. He told me that Remi had been shot in the chest and loaded with the other wounded in a truck and the truck in attempting to run a Chinese roadblock the truck was stopped, shot up and burned by the Chinese with all the wounded aboard. Trying to ascertain that Remi was on the truck I made contact with another guy from Mississippi in Remi's unit and he told me that he remembers giving Remi a cigarette on the truck just before the roadblock incident. Remember this all occurred in an area where zero degrees and no snow was considered a good day. Keep in touch, see if whoever has that portrait of Remi. I will add to this that I am glad our Mom never knew this ending of his life..
 
If you do any reading and can get the book titled East of The Chosin, author Roy Appleman you might find it interesting.

Saddest book I've ever read. It's somewhat technical, being written by a military man for a military audience, but if you understand the operational terms? It's an incomparable battle study, and the best monument that Task Force is ever likely to get. Those men were doomed from the start.

Thank you for posting. RIP to your brother. He drew the shortest possible straw. I agree about your mom. It was a bad, bad situation for those wounded men.
 
The other side of the battle was no less brutal. Against most, if not all senior CCP and military leadership, Mao decided to get involved in Korea. He knew that time was of essence so troops were sent across Yalu river in haste. As the troop trains were passing by Shenyang, the then Deputy Marshall for Northeast Command greeting on the platform were appalled to see that the troops weren't fitted for winter. He pleaded for the trains to stop a few hours, so he could send winter uniforms from local barracks, but was denied. There were records of an entire company frozen to death in a frigid NK night.

As lopsided as it were in Chosin in terms of manpower, Americans dealt heavy blows to Chinese corps-size task force, and escaped with about 100k+ civilian refugees in tow (quoting the figure from memory). No regimental size units suffered total loss.

The Chinese commander leading the campaign (Song Shilun) was heavily reprimanded for high casualties and failure to achieve objectives, and for many years the battle had not been publicly discussed as it was considered a huge military blunder. It isn't until just recent years, the propaganda machinery started bringing this up again, even made a movie for it last year, to stir up anti-America sentiment and military pride.
 
I post this on Facebook each Memorial day.

Memorial Day is the most expensive holiday there is. For every pool that is opened, every meal grilled, every beer opened, every yard game played, every ice cream enjoyed, there is a family remembering a photo of a loved one in uniform. That picture might be in living color, it might be sepia toned, it might be faded and cracked. No matter the state of the picture, it represents a life not lived. It represents family gathering around a closed casket, or no casket at all.

These folks never had the opportunity to live a life, they never had the chance to hang up the uniform and enjoy the nation they served.

We all owe it to them to live a life that pays something towards the sacrifice they made, because that butcher's bill will never be paid in full.
 
My brother was lost at Chosin Resorvoir on 2 December 1950. I had contacted a childhood friend of his about 7 years ago. His name was William G Mahar. Bill was able to tell me the events leading up to my brother's death as he was in Korea the at the same time period.

This is a copy of a remembrance entry at the Korean War Project by Mr. Mahar:

"I knew Remi growing up as kids in Westfield, went to his house High St. as I recall, ran into him again in Tokyo PX in the summer of 1950, stayed overnight at my unit in Tokyo on his way back up to Sendai to rejoin the 7th. Division, we had pictures taken together and I gave them to his mother when I returned from Korea in 1952. At the time she was living up near Noble Hospital. Later years talked to his 1st. Sgt. in Heavy Mortar Co up at the Chosin Reservoir. WGM"

I also located another friend of my brother that enlisted on the same day with him in 1948. His name was Gordon Snyder, also a Korean War vet. Gordon happened to be a ceremonial guard at the Agawam Veterans Memorial Cemetery. He contacted me after doing research so he could have a memorial erected at the cemetery for my brother, because it had to be done by family. I had to prove my relationship to the cemetery to get the stone put up, which did happen eventually.

Anyway, here is the letter that Bill Mahar had sent me. I posted this here a while ago, but I will do this every Memorial Day. Bill was in his 80's when he wrote this...

Remi and I used to fish together in the Westfield River over where the railroad bridge crosses from Elm to North Elm St. Met Remi in Tokyo at the snack bar in the PX., he had been down in Eta-jima school command attending a school and when the Korean War started the military closed the school and sent all the students back to their units, Remi was heading back to the 31st. Infantry Regiment, heavy mortar company, 7th. Infantry Division up in Northern Japan, Sendai. He stayed over night at my unit in Tokyo, then left the next day to report in to his unit. During his stay with me we had pictures(portrait) taken and when I got back to Westfield I took a picture of him and gave it to his mother, who at the time lived on W. Silver St. in a house across from Noble Hospital. It probably is around somewhere. My unit got to Korea ahead of his unit and when his unit got to Pusan Harbor on troop ships designated to the invasion of Inchon Harbor. I recall talking to a 7th. MP down on the docks in Pusan and mentioned Remi's unit to him and he pointed out the actual ship that the unit was on. Unfortunately I did not go out to see him as I figured I would see him up the line sometime. Never did. Remi was in the Inchon invasion and later was involved with the Chosin Reservoir operation. Where Remi's Regiment had 4 Chinese Divisions roll over them. If you do any reading and can get the book titled East of The Chosin, author Roy Appleman you might find it interesting. Talked a few years back to Remi's First Sgt(now dead) in Phoenix AZ. He told me that Remi had been shot in the chest and loaded with the other wounded in a truck and the truck in attempting to run a Chinese roadblock the truck was stopped, shot up and burned by the Chinese with all the wounded aboard. Trying to ascertain that Remi was on the truck I made contact with another guy from Mississippi in Remi's unit and he told me that he remembers giving Remi a cigarette on the truck just before the roadblock incident. Remember this all occurred in an area where zero degrees and no snow was considered a good day. Keep in touch, see if whoever has that portrait of Remi. I will add to this that I am glad our Mom never knew this ending of his life..
R.I.P. to your brother... I will have you and your family in my thoughts. We need to remember those who paid the ultimate sacrifice for our freedoms in this great country of ours. Freedom is not free when hard men and women are the ones losing their life for it.
 
Last edited:
RIP to your brother OP.


Saddest book I've ever read. It's somewhat technical, being written by a military man for a military audience, but if you understand the operational terms? It's an incomparable battle study, and the best monument that Task Force is ever likely to get. Those men were doomed from the start.

It's a good book. I'm reading it, but feel like I've read it before. Perhaps excerpts from other Korean War books I have.

Two incredibly shorthanded IN bns pushed to fill the area where the significantly larger USMC regiment had been sitting.

Hung out to dry by X Corps and 7ID.

During the initial set, the heavy mortar company was well positioned to support both 1/32 and 3/31.

IMG_0394.PNG
 
RIP to your brother OP.




It's a good book. I'm reading it, but feel like I've read it before. Perhaps excerpts from other Korean War books I have.

Two incredibly shorthanded IN bns pushed to fill the area where the significantly larger USMC regiment had been sitting.

Hung out to dry by X Corps and 7ID.

During the initial set, the heavy mortar company was well positioned to support both 1/32 and 3/31.

View attachment 757453
They did what they could with what they had, but they were out too far. Way too far. The problem came later (after this map), once Faith pulled back to the Inlet and the Chinese came around out of the hills to the east.
 
They did what they could with what they had, but they were out too far. Way too far. The problem came later (after this map), once Faith pulled back to the Inlet and the Chinese came around out of the hills to the east.

The fact they were cut off south of the inlet from day 1 didn't help much either. Would have taken a battalion+ to clear that.
 
This is one of the best Korean War documentaries I’ve seen, called “Hold At All Costs - The Battle for Outpost Harry”

200 Americans and Greeks on one OP against waves of thousands of Chinese. With interviews from American, Greek and Chinese survivors.

E24D5267-8DB6-4E61-9621-EA5F669649FE.jpeg


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwtcQzeREX4&pp=ygUXaG9sZCBhdCBhbGwgY29zdHMgbW92aWU%3D

 
Saddest book I've ever read. It's somewhat technical, being written by a military man for a military audience, but if you understand the operational terms? It's an incomparable battle study, and the best monument that Task Force is ever likely to get. Those men were doomed from the start.

Thank you for posting. RIP to your brother. He drew the shortest possible straw. I agree about your mom. It was a bad, bad situation for those wounded men.
For the more simple minded of us
View: https://youtu.be/LaciBfshyTo
 
Saddest book I've ever read. It's somewhat technical, being written by a military man for a military audience, but if you understand the operational terms? It's an incomparable battle study, and the best monument that Task Force is ever likely to get. Those men were doomed from the start.

Thank you for posting. RIP to your brother. He drew the shortest possible straw. I agree about your mom. It was a bad, bad situation for those wounded men.
Thank you. Remi was a bit older than me, but I remember him pretty clearly. He played with me alot.
 
God Bless your brother and all the other men and women who died and have served this great country. I know we get to enjoy this day off, with barbecues, pool openings and other things. I just hope it's never forgotten the price that was paid by so many and their families.
 
Usually GTG(getogether) with armed services personal, unlike myself.
I fume thinking about MacNamara's morons. Send in the children. grrrrrrrrrrr
 
Last edited:
RIP Remi.
Check out "The Coldest Winter" by David Halberstam, great book and I believe last one he wrote before his death.
I've told this story before, I was in the 187th Infantry Brigade (SEP) in Boston and was asked to participate in a Color Guard for a Reunion of the Chosin Few in Norwood in 1990 I believe. I had no clue about the battle of the Chosin Reservoir, we showed up, presented the Colors and sat down to listen to Tom Hudner's speech (MOH). Men were crying and I was stunned I knew nothing about this Battle. Capt. Hudner shook our hands and thanked us for showing up in our ugly Greens. Very emotional day, I was the old guy and my fellow Soldiers who were young and dumb didn't get it..
 
My uncle MCDONELL GEORGE F Capt. North Korean POW death camp 2 1950-53 was 6’4” 200 pounds when captured, when repatriated he was 90 pounds & lost all he front teeth cuz he laughed at his captors and all his teeth were knocked out by a steel buttstock of a guards rifle. I can honestly say there are somethings worse than death. His career was destroyed because he was a POW in Korea, a suspected communist sleeper agent, the rest followed. I remember meeting him, for he retired as a lieutenant colonel, and I do forget where that was.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0742.jpeg
    IMG_0742.jpeg
    761.3 KB · Views: 13
  • IMG_0744.jpeg
    IMG_0744.jpeg
    878.4 KB · Views: 14
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom