Walther P99c and Sig p225

nxtgto87

NES Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Messages
81
Likes
9
Feedback: 28 / 0 / 0
I've been looking for a 9mm handgun for a little while now. I have a Glock 29 10mm right now that is phenomenal. Fun to shoot, packs a big punch and will be my primary carry pistol. But it is expensive to shoot. I've been looking for a 9mm that I could practice with at the range a good amount and is also concealable under just a Tshirt in warmer weather.

The Sig p225 and Walther P99c seem to have crept to the top of my list.
It seems that the P99 AS has one of the best triggers available in a DA/SA and the ergonomics of it are really great (I've held one, but not shot it). The size makes it very concealable. Walther seems to fly under the radar but is very high quality from my research.

The P225 is a pretty thin single stack 9mm. The contour of the grip feels good in my hand even though it is thin. I took a course at the Sig Academy and used a 229 9mm which felt good but I think would be too big to conceal without heavier clothing. The P225 seems to have a proven track record and dimensionally seems to fit the bill.

I haven't had the opportunity to shoot either of feel the triggers, just fondle them in a shop. I also considered the USP Compact 9mm and the P239. However the USPc quality differences don't seem to justify the MA prices (maybe I'm wrong however). The P239 felt too thin in my hand with the stock grips and the Hogue rubber grips pinched my middle finger underneath the triggerguard, just couldn't get comfortable.

Any personal experience and opinions that could be provided on either one would be really helpful. I'm taking another course at the Sig Academy soon and I'd like to use one of my own pistols as they don't allow 10mm on their range.
 
P99 is an awesome gun, i'd take it any day over a 225. fits like it was made for my hand.

FIFY


Seriously though, I have a full size p99 and absolutely love it. I bought it used with an unknown round count and it hasn't jammed once since I got it, over 4K rounds.
 
The 225 all the way. Accurate and reliable. I had one and sold it many years ago, and still kicking myself to this day. I will definitely get another if one comes along at a decent price.
 
I haven't tried the Walther.
The Sig 225 is a tackdriving machine. Kinda blocky looking IMO, but very high quality.

Did you consider a G19?

I did think about a G19 or G26. I want to have something in DA/SA for now though just to diversify a little bit. If I don't like the DA/SA then I'll probably go straight to a G19 though.

It seems the P225 has a bit more support. The Walther definitely seems to fly under the radar, but those who have one seem to love it. Interesting..
 
I love my P225/P6 - carry it regularly. Reliable "to hell and back" as they say at Sig, and it's an awfully comfortable gun to shoot. The controls are intuitive, (for me) and the only issue I ever really had was learning not to ride the slide lock with my big hands.

Where are you located? I bet you could find a member here to let you try their Walther or Sig.

-edit- The other PITA on the Sig is mag availability. The aftermarket ProMags are crap, and they don't make factory mags any more so they're a little spendy; $30 or so. If you're patient you can find 2/$40 sometimes on the classifieds here or elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
I love my P225/P6 - carry it regularly. Reliable "to hell and back" as they say at Sig, and it's an awfully comfortable gun to shoot. The controls are intuitive, (for me) and the only issue I ever really had was learning not to ride the slide lock with my big hands.

Where are you located? I bet you could find a member here to let you try their Walther or Sig.

-edit- The other PITA on the Sig is mag availability. The aftermarket ProMags are crap, and they don't make factory mags any more so they're a little spendy; $30 or so. If you're patient you can find 2/$40 sometimes on the classifieds here or elsewhere.

I'm from Peabody up here on the northshore. I did happen to notice the mags are a little pricey, even the Walther ones aren't cheap. The P225 despite being an older design, has a lot of support here, maybe thats why they don't come up for sale very often..
 
I'm from Peabody up here on the northshore. I did happen to notice the mags are a little pricey, even the Walther ones aren't cheap. The P225 despite being an older design, has a lot of support here, maybe thats why they don't come up for sale very often..

Keep an eye out for the Sig P6 - it's the Police version of the P225, and often times less expensive as they tend to come with holster wear. The only difference that I know of is the skeletal hammer used on the P6 so a department armorer was easily able to see if the pistol had been dropped. You'll find them arriving here in bunches (though less now than five or ten years ago) as they come from German police departments who have switched to a new sidearm.

Can't help you with a shooting trial, unfortunately - I'm in Pittsfield a couple hours away.
 
Keep an eye out for the Sig P6 - it's the Police version of the P225, and often times less expensive as they tend to come with holster wear. The only difference that I know of is the skeletal hammer used on the P6 so a department armorer was easily able to see if the pistol had been dropped. You'll find them arriving here in bunches (though less now than five or ten years ago) as they come from German police departments who have switched to a new sidearm.

Can't help you with a shooting trial, unfortunately - I'm in Pittsfield a couple hours away.

I will definitely keep an eye out for the P6's. I googled the differences and it seems some say they have a heavier mainspring along with the different hammer you mentioned. I'd imagine the P225 will have less recoil being heavier but hopefully the trigger pull would be as nice as the P229 I used for my SigAcademy course.

Thanks for the information. Still a tough decision nonetheless. Its tough trying to pick just one.
 
Back
Top Bottom