-
If you enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for a NES Membership The benefits pay for the membership many times over.
Which current production revolver for carry?
- Thread starter Coyote33
- Start date
one-eyed Jack
Manufacturer
Any snubbie in .357. Jack.
sjohnston0311
NES Member
S&W 442 wasn't an option so I voted for the 642, whis is basically the same gun in a different finish. I don't normally carry a revolver, but sometimes throwing the j-frame in my pocket is a good option for carrying a gun when I don't feel like carrying a gun.
I think any of the S&W or Ruger revolvers you have up there would be a good choice. Ruger does make an LCR in .327 Federal Magnum, which gives you six rounds instead of the 5 you'll get with the 38 or the 357, so that's something to consider.
The Ruger SP101 is a great option too, but not exactly "light weight".
I think any of the S&W or Ruger revolvers you have up there would be a good choice. Ruger does make an LCR in .327 Federal Magnum, which gives you six rounds instead of the 5 you'll get with the 38 or the 357, so that's something to consider.
The Ruger SP101 is a great option too, but not exactly "light weight".
FrankNA
NES Member
Here's my choice if I didn't live in this commie hell hole! It's a f--king revolver and these @ssholes still have to f--k with us!!!! Lightweight, 6 rounds, .38/.357 mag and easily concealable.
Kimber K6s 3" DASA
Update: January 2023 - I found a lightly used K6s DASA 3” for sale from a fellow NES’r. Quite impressed with this revolver! At just over 25 oz., 6 round capacity and being fairly compact, it makes for a great CC revolver. Shoots great in both SA or DA and feels good in my hand with the slightly larger Kimber walnut target grips that provide a full 3 finger purchase on the grip. Currently CC’ing in a Garrett Industries Silent Thunder kydex/leather lined IWB holster. I like this holster as it had a short lead time but it’s also tuckable which allows for CC with your shirt tucked in your pants. Waiting (30+) weeks for my Milt Sparks VM II as it’s my favorite holster and I much prefer leather over kydex.
Kimber K6s 3" DASA
Update: January 2023 - I found a lightly used K6s DASA 3” for sale from a fellow NES’r. Quite impressed with this revolver! At just over 25 oz., 6 round capacity and being fairly compact, it makes for a great CC revolver. Shoots great in both SA or DA and feels good in my hand with the slightly larger Kimber walnut target grips that provide a full 3 finger purchase on the grip. Currently CC’ing in a Garrett Industries Silent Thunder kydex/leather lined IWB holster. I like this holster as it had a short lead time but it’s also tuckable which allows for CC with your shirt tucked in your pants. Waiting (30+) weeks for my Milt Sparks VM II as it’s my favorite holster and I much prefer leather over kydex.
Last edited:
Funny that you posted this now. I'm looking for a 642/442 myself. Just want something to toss in the pocket that won't cause my pants to fall down. I normally prefer stainless, but the 442 actually interests me more since it will be less visible. Love Model 60's and SP101's, but way too heavy for pocket carry. Didn't think about the 638, but now that you brought that up, I like the idea of DA/SA but "no snag". It's just hard to find one of the above right now that is reasonably priced without the "Hillary Hole". I want light this time, but not any of the "poly" ones.
zboys
NES Member
I just listed my 442 in the classifieds.
tuna
NES Member
I’m not a fan of the LCR, so I’d go with other. Either a Charter or Taurus would be my choice before a current smith.
I don’t actually have any current production guns I want. An old smith 36 with the hammer mounted firing pin would be my first choice.
I don’t actually have any current production guns I want. An old smith 36 with the hammer mounted firing pin would be my first choice.
HorizontalHunter
NES Member
Ruger LCR 38. It was priced right and it is great to toss in a pocket. I bought it thinking my wife may like it but I carry it far more than I thought I would.
I did change the factory front sight out for a tritium night sight. Not a lot of Snub nose revolvers have a replaceable front sight if that is a factor for you.
Bob
I did change the factory front sight out for a tritium night sight. Not a lot of Snub nose revolvers have a replaceable front sight if that is a factor for you.
Bob
Is that the Black version of the 642?
Whenever these threads come up about the 642, I get excited.
Their semi autos are junk but I guess they still make good revolvers.
I want something for a jacket pocket because no Glock is that small.
Due to my increased belly, I'm going up to size 44 pants which allows for a G19.
I just really like the iconic 642.
Every time I see the logo on that revolver, I think about this 80's vintage T-shirt and what that revolver should be loaded up with.
![[smile]](/xen/styles/default/xenforo/smilies.vb/001.gif "Smile [smile]")
Like @03KnockKnock I usually carry a S&W 442.
S&W 340 PD.
I carry the 640-2 in an OWB crossdraw from Triple K. It also fits well in a jacket pocket or the front pocket of my Carhartts.
I also own a Ruger SP101. I like that it has a hammer so i can roll it to SA if i want to shoot a little more slowly. Because of the hammer, it doesn’t pocket ride as well.
They both shoot Remington Golden Sabres and Winchester Silvertips very well.
I also own a Ruger SP101. I like that it has a hammer so i can roll it to SA if i want to shoot a little more slowly. Because of the hammer, it doesn’t pocket ride as well.
They both shoot Remington Golden Sabres and Winchester Silvertips very well.
I carry a 442 with a trigger job done by Dave Santurri, can barely feel it’s there sometimes. Had a 340sc but sold it. Should have kept it so I had the option of shooting .357 mag. You live and learn though.
mu2bdriver
NES Member
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2009
- Messages
- 1,654
- Likes
- 2,231
This. I've shot other lightweight ones that are mentioned above but none of them compare in my opinion.
I owned a 638 and it was a beautiful gun. Obviously any snub is going to kick and that was certainly the case with mine (I would never want to shoot .357 out of a gun with a 2" barrel, but call me a wuss). I'd do 50rds at a time at the range and that would feel like more than enough. Personally, I'd steer clear from Charter Arms/Taurus unless money is the predominant factor. From what I've handled myself, the build quality, lock-up, and finishing are sub-par.
If you can shoot full power loads out of a scandium 357 without flinching you can then shoot anything smooth.
-sweet old lady voice in the gun range-
"Excuse me young man would you mind moving over one your muzzle blast is coming into my stall."
My advice is to get a ct laser grip and dry fire all day until the red dot doesn't dance around on the wall at trigger break.
I can make a baseball sized group fast at 10 yards. Grip strength is everything. You don't want that thing moving in your hands, will bruise your hands like when you hold a shotgun wrong.
-sweet old lady voice in the gun range-
"Excuse me young man would you mind moving over one your muzzle blast is coming into my stall."
My advice is to get a ct laser grip and dry fire all day until the red dot doesn't dance around on the wall at trigger break.
I can make a baseball sized group fast at 10 yards. Grip strength is everything. You don't want that thing moving in your hands, will bruise your hands like when you hold a shotgun wrong.
Model 340PD | Smith & Wesson
Matte black scandium alloy frame; titanium alloy barrel.
Very nice gun but you're only popping off a couple .357 mags (@whatluck, hot loads, OUCH) per sitting.
Have a GREAT SUNDAY guys!
