Diagnose my AR Malfunction

I might head down to AFS this week to meet up with someone buying some MP5 stuff off of me and sight my AR-15 in while i'm there. If you want we can meet up and i'll try to help you troubleshoot it.

I have a pre-ban Colt lower that also registered as a SBR so we can put any upper we like on it for testing.

Drop me a PM and we can figure it out if you want.
 
I did this test per your earlier post and felt a click when I released the trigger. I'm pretty sure I did the test as you indicated.

OK, that's helpful. Can you try the same test with the upper on and no mag in the gun? Pull the charging handle back while holding the trigger back, then release the charging handle. Slowly release the trigger. Basically, can you reproduce the problem when manually cycling the gun?
 
OK, that's helpful. Can you try the same test with the upper on and no mag in the gun? Pull the charging handle back while holding the trigger back, then release the charging handle. Slowly release the trigger. Basically, can you reproduce the problem when manually cycling the gun?


Been playing around with it for a bit now, I can't reproduce the malfunction.
 
If the rifle cycles fine and only issue is that the trigger doesn't reset, this eliminates upper issues, magazine issues, and ammo issues.

My guess is that the trigger/disconnector have been assembled incorrectly. In particular, I'd bet a small amount (these are tough times) that the disconnector spring is installed upside down.

Here is the test:

First, with rifle unloaded, separate the upper and lower; put the upper aside.

Second, works best if you can chuck the lower using a "Flipper" or perhaps a cleaning holder that grips the butt stock.

Third, be sure that, in doing the following, you do not allow the hammer to strike the rear of the magazine well, which it will damage. Either use a hammer strike block or your fingers to capture the hammer fall.

Test: With finger off the trigger and safety off, cock the hammer. Based on your report, it should cock fine. Now, pull trigger (again: capture and cushion hammer strike); hammer should fall. Do not release trigger. With your other hand, and while still holding the trigger back, recock the hammer; it should be caught by the disconnector. Now (again, taking care not to let the hammer fall and strike the magwell), release the trigger slowly and see if the disconnector releases the hammer to the sear face. If it does not, you have a hammer/disconnector problem. As I said, most likely an assembly error and most likely disconnector spring installed upside down.
 
Been playing around with it for a bit now, I can't reproduce the malfunction.

Interesting. If it's a lower issue I would expect it to be reproducible. As suggested earlier, trying another lower (and a different upper on your lower) may be the way to go.
 
Interesting. If it's a lower issue I would expect it to be reproducible. As suggested earlier, trying another lower (and a different upper on your lower) may be the way to go.

I suspect he is finding that the trigger resets just fine each time he cycles the action via the charging handle with his finger off the trigger.

Try dry firing (I'm assuming the upper and lower are assembled together) and then, without removing finger from trigger, cycle action via the charging handle. Slowly release trigger; should hear (and maybe feel) the reset. Then pull the trigger (same assumption); does hammer drop.
 
I

Try dry firing (I'm assuming the upper and lower are assembled together) and then, without removing finger from trigger, cycle action via the charging handle. Slowly release trigger; should hear (and maybe feel) the reset. Then pull the trigger (same assumption); does hammer drop.

Unlike the failure, it drops.

I'm pulling the charging handle with the trigger depressed, when I come off the trigger I can hear (and feel) the click, when I pull the trigger the hammer falls. So, at this point I can't reproduce the failure, but I plan to mess around with a lot more.
 
I suppose it is possible that you got some crude in the fire control that was interfering with operation and then since was blown out. I've never seen that, but I've heard reports along those lines.

Intermittent problems are the hardest to fix.
 
I put 80 rounds throuhg it yesterday with zero malfunctions. I'm still not confident that the problems is fixed, but it was fun shooting it at least. I'll probably replace the LPK at some point anyways.

Thanks to everyone for all the advice.
 
Back
Top Bottom