first handgun advice glock 26 or walther pps?

Joined
Feb 1, 2012
Messages
390
Likes
38
Feedback: 0 / 0 / 0
hey everyone. planning on getting my first CCW handgun soon. I was wondering what everyones thoughts were on the Glock 26 vs the Walther PPS in terms of carrying and shooting. I like the PPS because of its most attractive feature, the thing is wicked thin. Im a thin person so i feel like that might print less than the g26.

what are your thoughts?
 
I just got a PPS, you're right about thin, that thing would disappear. Only thing is it needs a trigger job out of the box, the pull was so heavy that it affected my accuracy a hell of a lot and it just wasn't pleasant to shoot. Its in the shop right now getting that taken care of. I plan on using it for summer carry. You're also at a disadvantage in terms of capacity compared to the 26 but if you don't mind having 6-8 rounds to work with (depending on mag) its a good choice.

As far as the Glock, I have a 19 which I also plan to carry (waiting on holster). I'm also a thin guy (132 lb) and I have no worries about it printing so long as I dress accordingly. I hear the recoil of the 26 isn't much worse than a 19 and the only thing you should consider is if you're comfortable with just 2 fingers on the grip. The longer 7 and 8 PPS mags allow me to get all 3 fingers on it comfortably.
 
Is this your first gun, or the first gun that you are going to carry? If it is your first gun, then I would look for something bigger that is easier to shoot. Subcompact guns are not the best choice to use when learning marksmanship.

If you are going to carry in a belt holster, then I'd get a 19 over a 26 -- once you are wearing a cover garment, you can conceal 19 just as easily and it will be easier to shoot well.
 
its both, first gun and first carry gun.

ive held the 26 before and found it a tad difficult with only two fingers on but if i was to get one, or the PPS, i would use the extended mag for the extra grip length.

thanks for the responses guys.i just want to find a PPS in the area that i could get a hold of to see if i like the grips on it.

132lbs? jeeze, i thought i was thin. im 150 but im also 6 foot 3 inches so im pretty lanky.
 
The only way I would get the Glock 26 was if you were going to carry it in a pocket (though it is too thick for me to pocket carry). Seriously, if you are going to carry in a belt holster, you can just as easily carry the 19, and you will learn marksmanship faster with the 19 than the 26. The 26 is going to magnify any marksmanship mistakes that you make.

If you can, go to a rental range that has both and try them out.
 
yeah i plan on doing just that once i get my LTC. Just took my course at MFS the other day, just need to wait a few weeks till im 21 then im going to apply.

also, youre near framingham? i go to FSU lol. cant have a gun up here though
 
Try them both. I like the G26 and the G19 is Probably the best all-purpose self defense gun around in 9mm, other opinions vary :D Much better in free states do the redonculous mag restrictions in MA.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk
 
I have both a 19 and a 26. My vote is for the 26 over the 19 and the PPS.

If you are going to carry a 19, you may as well carry a 30. I know I absolutely love mine.
 
I've shot and carried both. You can't go wrong with either of them. In an odd way, the thicker 26 is a little easier to conceal for me, particularly compared to the 7 round mag in the PPS. But that's a small point. Both guns are made for concealed carry. They feel radically different in the hand, so try both before you buy. In Mass, you definitely want to fix the PPS trigger if you go that route.

Crossbreed makes holsters for both and they are the best I've found. Look at their Supertuck, though for these subcompact sized guns I like their QuickClip model even better. The comp-tac MTAC is comparable to Crossbreed's Supertuck if you want a second option.

I've become a little picky about the sights I use and that's one reason to favor the 26. There are tons of options out there for replacement sights and night sights. For the PPS choices are much more limited.

I'll agree with the posters who say that neither is an ideal first gun purchase. These are small guns designed for concealed carry. A larger pistol will be easier to handle and more comfortable for practice. If you want just one gun, the Glock 19 is by far the best all purpose handgun out there. Or, go with the 26 and pick up a 17 or 19 for the range, depending on which grip fits you best. For the PPS, you want a range gun that allows you to practice using the mag release, so look at a Walther P99. While you are at it, check out the Walther P99 compact which is fairly comparable in size to the Glock 26.
 
thanks for all the info guys. would you suggest maybe getting a compact glock, instead of a subcompact, for range/carry use instead? im just concerned with the size and concealability.
 
thanks for all the info guys. would you suggest maybe getting a compact glock, instead of a subcompact, for range/carry use instead? im just concerned with the size and concealability.

Personally, I would just get a Glock 19. Carry it for a few months, practice a lot, and then decide if you really need anything else.
 
Personally, I would just get a Glock 19. Carry it for a few months, practice a lot, and then decide if you really need anything else.
This.

How well it conceals is a matter of a good gun belt, holster choice, and dressing around it.
 
oddly enough, as a thin guy myself, I have no issues concealing any full size. Good holster and belt is a must.
As for the 2 you listed, both great guns. PPS=lower capacity is basically the only down side.
Good luck, and let us know which way you go.

Welcome aboard!
 
I have a G19, G26 and a PPS. most often I carry the PPS in a IWB holster. I changed out the disconnector myself. The Glock magazines are easier to carry in your pocket. The PPS magazines have a stupid plastic foot that extends 1/2".
 
I am in the same boat as you, thinking to get a G26 as a CCW. I own a G19 with a Blackhawk hostler, and I want to get something a little smaller to carry.

G19 was the first firearm I bought; I shot few other pistols of that size, and I found the G19 was the most comfortable and control-able before I picked her up at FS.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom