I need a .357 - which one?

Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
1,160
Likes
82
Location
Saugus, PRM
Feedback: 5 / 0 / 0
I've decided to add a .357 to my slowly growing collection, but I'm not sure which one to get. I would like something with a barrel around 6 inches. While I would love a Colt Python, I'm fairly certain that it's well outside of my budget.

Should I go for a Smith & Wesson 686? Any drawbacks to the ones that hold 7 rounds?

What about a Ruger Blackhawk convertible? This would enable me to shoot .357, 38spl, and 9mm all from the same gun. I am used to single action with my .44 (old 3 screw flattop) so it's not that big of a drawback not having DA.

Should I just go with something like a GP100?
 
The only drawback to the 7 round 686 is IDPA or any other shooting game that only allows revolver divisions to load 6 rounds. The GP100 is another solid option, and cheaper than the 686. I agree 100% about the Python. Beautiful guns, but too costly.
 
S&W revolvers are nice if you don't mind the absurd lock.

IMO, go for a 3" or 4" Ruger GP100. I have the 3" SS model and I love it. Tough as nails, accurate, and inexpensive.
 
If I was buying a full size revolver I'd buy an SW 627, unless, as Jar suggests, you were going to use it for "gun gaming", in which case a 6 shot is often
better/less confusing.

-Mike
 
I had a 6" blue S&W Mod 19 years ago that I sold.I really miss it.However I just bought a Ruger GP 100 Stainless 6incher and its a great shooter.The trigger had to be lightened a tad but it reall shoots well out to 50 yds.With better eyes I am sure that distance could be expanded.
 
Why buy a new revolver when there are so many great used S&Ws on the market???

My S&W 686 has a sweet double action pull and the most amazing single action trigger of any firearm I've ever fired (including any custom 1911). It's prelock and has a hammer mounted firing pin.

I got it for 327.00 on Gunbroker.

These guns are out theres if you look.
 
Admittedly, I'm not really a revolver guy, but I've very happy with my SW 686. Low maintenance, reliable, durable, accurate, just not a 1911 :)

686_1.JPG
 
Admittedly, I'm not really a revolver guy, but I've very happy with my SW 686. Low maintenance, reliable, durable, accurate, just not a 1911 :)

686_1.JPG

You know, I'm not a 'revolver guy' either (I have 2, a 686 and a 617), and I'm obsessed with my 1911s (I have 4 with plans for 2 more), but if I had to choose one...

I'd take my 686 over any of my guns, including my 1911s.
 
Look for a NIB or lightly used Smith from the 1970s. They are not that hard to find. Some of the best quality and hands down the finest factory triggers.

Something like the "Highway Patrolman" model 28-2 would provide you with one of the finest .357's ever made.
 
Its pretty hard to go wrong with a Ruger Blackhawk convertable:

357Blackhawk-vi.jpg


This one dates to '76.
Dont' expect accuracy miracles with the 9mm cylinder.
Some ammo shoots well and some is like throwing rocks.
You are putting a .355 bullet through a .358 bore.
The gun shoots .38 Spl and .357 very nicely.[smile]

There are many other options from the 686 or M28, through the M640:

3X357-vi.jpg


The 8-3/8" M686 is a hoot to shoot!
The M640 is less than 'shooter friendly'[wink]

I just like them all, especially the 7-shot 686:

pc686p1-vi.jpg


I don't have photos handy of the GP100 or my three Security-Sixes, but you get the idea...buy one of each.[shocked]

Why don't you set a budget and put a WTB in the classifieds. I've bought most of my dozen or so .357s for less than you might think.

Jack
 
I've got a fairly decent story about one particular Dan Wesson.

So here's a little background: The Dan Wesson factory was located in Monson, MA, my hometown. My grandmother worked at the factory for many years assembling these fine revolvers. She would engrave her name on the area under the grip of guns she assembled. If you own a Dan Wesson, and the name engraved on the handle area is Andy(short for Adrienne) then the gun was assembled by her.During the time she worked at the factory, my father bought a 6" barrel .357. He told me it was somewhere in the early 70's when he bought the gun.

On to the story: Back in '96 we moved into a new house(still in Monson) the house got broken into about 4 months after we moved in. Among other personal items stolen was the Dan Wesson .357. Assuming the gun was lost forever, the insurance company replaced the Dan Wesson with a shiny, new Smith & Wesson .357. My father put this gun away and to this day has never shot it!

Fastforward to ten years later, 2006: We got a call from Hartford, CT police saying the gun was recovered in a drug bust, and my father could drive down and pick up the gun. He was working at the time, so my grandfather went and picked up the gun. We were amazed the gun was recovered and back in our posession after 10 years.

This summer my grandfather, who was a police officer, and chief of police in Monson for years, gave me an ammo can with approximately 400 rounds of .357 from back when he was on the force. So the only wheelgun I own being a .38 snubbie, I asked my father if I could use one of his .357's. (He also has my grandfather's .357 which is engraved with his name and badge number.) So after deciding not to let me use the unfired S&W, he gives me the Dan Wesson to borrow for the day.

Having not been cleaned since before the gun was stolen, it was caked with fingerprinting powder and had some rust. I thoroughly cleaned it and took it to the range. It was still accurate and a blast to shoot. The pachmayr grip and heavy barrel design of the Dan Wesson made it a pleasure to shoot. I'll try and get some pictures of the gun when I'm home this weekend.

Sorry for the thread drift and my rambling. The thought of Dan Wesson .357's brought back good memories of my grandmother, her stories about the factory (and her favorite about assmebling the kit guns with interchangeable barrels) and the amazing fact that the gun was recovered, and the fun I had when I fired the Dan Wesson for the first time in well over 10 years.

Oh yea, and the town demo'd the Dan Wesson Building this summer. Too much money to clean up the hazmat stuff and remodel.

Here's a couple pictures of the building before it was torn down.

100_01001.JPG

100_0101.JPG


Originally the building was a school. Thats a "lamp of wisdom" above the entrance, made of granite that was mined from the quarry in Monson around 1900.



Again, sorry for the long story and thread drift. Just wanted to share the story with y'all.
 
You know, I'm not a 'revolver guy' either (I have 2, a 686 and a 617), and I'm obsessed with my 1911s (I have 4 with plans for 2 more), but if I had to choose one...

I'd take my 686 over any of my guns, including my 1911s.

+1
I'm not a "revolver guy" either, actually right now my 686-5 prelock is the only wheelgun I own... but it would be one of the last guns I ever sell... I had my action done over by S+W... what a nice trigger it has on it now. One of these days I'm going to get a nice holster for it to carry it as a woods gun.

-Mike
 
Four Seasons has a bunch of 686's on their used list. A 4 inch 686 is the perfect "all around" .357 revolver, IMHO. Pre-lock versions are readily available on the used market.
 
Back
Top Bottom