What's your recommendation for a compact concealed carry gun?

[larry.k]

Just looking for recommendations, or dis-recommendations. I'm not carrying, but licensed to. At this point I'm using a Glock 17 for practice, and a Mk 4 Colt 1911 for fun. Both are to big for concealed carry, in my opinion. Thank you. larry.k

 

[MAD Geary]

If your familiar with you glock 17, go down a size or two with the 19,26 or 43. All great carry guns.

 

[Glockster30]

There are many subcompacts, compacts, and revolvers. Have you tried shooting any of them at a rental range or with friends?

 

[falcon123]

I carry a shield in 9mm. Very comfy and hardly notice it at all.

 

[M1911]

For carrying on a belt holster, Glock 19. For pocket carry, Kahr PM9 or maybe a Glock 43.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[jrsigp239]

Sig 938...perfect.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk

 

[Queen Bee]

If your familiar with you glock 17, go down a size or two with the 19,26 or 43. All great carry guns.

add the glock 42 to that list for glocks that are great. i carry a 19 mostly , or a 42 when i cannot truly carry a gun due to clothing restrictions.

 

[Golddiggie]

HK45C

/thread...


















oh, and IBTL

 

[Gammon]

38 or 9mm 2 in barrel revolver. Small, easy to conceal and can be fired from inside your pocket more than once.

PS I would have recommended a short barreled five shot 45 ACP revolver that accepts moon clips but no one makes such a gun. Are you listening, S&W?

 

[sig shooter]

I would go with a commander sized 1911 for carry. The familiarity with the 1911 platform makes it a logical choice.

 

[Gammon]

I would go with a commander sized 1911 for carry. The familiarity with the 1911 platform makes it a logical choice.

The only advantage of the Commander is a little less weight. The slightly shorter barrel and slide don't make it much easier to conceal or carry.

 

[sig shooter]

The only advantage of the Commander is a little less weight. The slightly shorter barrel and slide don't make it much easier to conceal or carry.

I disagree, the reduction in weight and size helps in the long term. A good thick and stiff belt and good holster make the biggest difference. Also, if the OP enjoys the 1911 system: flicking off the safety when on target, a commander would make a great choice.

 

[M1911]

I disagree, the reduction in weight and size helps in the long term. A good thick and stiff belt and good holster make the biggest difference. Also, if the OP enjoys the 1911 system: flicking off the safety when on target, a commander would make a great choice.

I disagree. The hardest part to conceal is the butt. A "compact" (Commander slide, officer's frame) is easier to conceal than a Commander. I have 7 1911s. 5 full size, 2 compact. The commander doesn't fill a niche for me.

 

[Marine-daughter]

G19 or G43.

 

[Mountain]

If you are leaning Glock:

Pocket carry or holster if you want = Glock 43
Holster carry or less convenient pocket carry = Glock 26
Holster carry only = Glock 19, 23, etc.

If you prefer hammer fired and something with a little more 'beef', check out a Sig P220 Compact. Too heavy for pocket carry but easy to conceal with a IWB holster.

So... Depends upon how you plan to carry and what platform you prefer.

 

[marleythefish]

i carry a sig xo full size 1911, everyone's different i guess. i used to carry a ruger sr9c, it carried very nicely in a crossbreed supertuck, but i prefer the .45.

 

[MAD Geary]

add the glock 42 to that list for glocks that are great. i carry a 19 mostly , or a 42 when i cannot truly carry a gun due to clothing restrictions.

True, that's what I actually carry most days. I should of added that to the list.

 

[Bt74]

I would go with a commander sized 1911 for carry. The familiarity with the 1911 platform makes it a logical choice.

I carry a RIA 9mm compact Tac 1911. 3 1/2" barrel. Heavy, but one of the most accurate pistols I own. Blasted a woodchuck at 50' a couple of days ago.....made a mess of my home office window screen though.

 

[92G]

I disagree. The hardest part to conceal is the butt. A "compact" (Commander slide, officer's frame) is easier to conceal than a Commander. I have 7 1911s. 5 full size, 2 compact. The commander doesn't fill a niche for me.

i have never carried a 1911, but would imagine there may be a role for the commander in horizontal shoulder carry? for vertical obviously could just go full size govt model, but horizontal with a govt model would almost certainly print in the back due to barrel length. so maybe the commander might be better? i have zero experience w 1911's but do like shoulder carry so that' best i can imagine in favor of commander.

OP, here are my carry faves:

HK P30sk or P2000sk - IWB
G19 or G32 - shoulder
G26, G42 - IWB or shoulder
M&P shield 9 - IWB
LCR 38 - ankle
G42 - ankle

 

[Waher]

Whatever compact fits your grip comfortably.

 

[Toe Knee]

Whatever compact fits your grip comfortably.

I agree 100%!

Conceal-ability and shooting comfort is important to me. I like to shoot what is in my carry rotation often and I want those 2 things out of the box with out modifications.

Price points, brand name or bragging rights are nice for range toys but i want something that is hiccup free and something I can shoot well out of the box all day long.

For carrying purposes I've owned or own:
1) S&W J frame 642
2) Ruger LCR .357
3) Ruger LCR 9mm
4) Shield 40
5) M&P 9c
5) Ruger SR9c
6) SR40c
7) Sig 938 (rosewood if it matters)
8) Ruger LC9s
9) Walther PPS M2

I like testing new and different options and have a lot of fun doing it.
FOR ME, I most liked option 7 for conceal-ability and 5 for all day shoot-ability.

That said 8+9 have proven best FOR ME. 8 for summer. 9 for fall/winter.

Subject to change.

 

[S. Kelly]

S&W M&P45c

 

[Sawicki1991]

Situation depending. In summer or with light clothing I carry my kel-tec p11. If I'm wearing shorts I drop in my Glock 42. With heavier clothing I carry my M&P45c. If your looking for a nice light ccw Glock 42/43 are nice. I went with the 42 because of the easier to control recoil in a small platform.

 

[Darkstar888]

I strongly suggest you consider a Walther. Either a a P99c (my choice) or a PPS M2 if you want a single stack. What I like about the P99c aside from its general sexiness, reliability, and excellent ergonomics is the ability to carry a full size 15rd backup mag with a grip adaptor as well as 10+1 in the gun. If you prefer a single stack the PPS M2 beats out the G43 and even Performance Center Shield in every comparison article and vid on the net.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Toe Knee]

.............If you prefer a single stack the PPS M2 beats out the G43 and even Performance Center Shield in every comparison article and vid on the net.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Very badass little pistol.

 

[Chet0729]

I like the Sigs, 238 and 938. Comfortable to carry IWB and small enough to pocket carry if you want to. I have had very good luck with both.
For the dont do its, S&W Bodyguard 380. Horrible trigger and prone to issues.

 

[wwit]

Whatever compact fits your grip comfortably.

^^^^^This wins the thread^^^^^

For me, its my Shield 9mm.

I don't like to advertise. So what feels good, comfortable and can be really concealed is the best bet IMHO.

 

[Al-Jim19]

If you already have a G17 I'd go for a G26 - carry the G17 mags as backups!

Id skip the G19 in favor of the G26 just because I'd say the 26 would be a little more varied from the 17.

 

[22lr]

I am a big fan of the PM9

 

[northny]

Another vote for Sig 938. I like the colt officers and is was my main edc for 25+ years. But it is heavy. Plus in warmer half of year tough to conceal.