- Joined
- Jul 28, 2016
- Messages
- 649
- Likes
- 909
That is a nice gun, and you should get it if you want it. And in an all steel N-frame, .357 is not a big deal. It will have some recoil, but nothing like an aluminum J-frame. I also don't think it being a snubby makes too much difference for shooting comfort. The short barrel may affect the velocity of .357 significantly, but that is a separate issue.
The one thing I will comment on is the unfluted cylinder. I know some people really like the look of it, but extra weight on the cylinder has disadvantages in a double action revolver. When you pull the double action trigger, your finger strength has to rotate the cylinder. The heavier the cylinder is, the more effort that takes. Compared to the weight of cocking the mainspring, the cylinder weight is a minor issue, but it still matters.
And then once the cylinder is moving, the cylinder stop has to stop it. When the cylinder is moving fast in rapid double action, there is significant impact on the cylinder stop, the notches in the cylinder, and on the frame where the cylinder stop protrudes. Over time, these are significant wear areas in a revolver, and the heavy cylinder of an N-frame is especially prone to peen all of these areas.
For slow shooting, and for moderate amounts of shooting, the unfluted cylinder will certainly be fine. But a fluted cylinder is always my preference. I also find it amusing that an unfluted cylinder is often included on a premium model, and costs more. Yet the unfluted cylinder has less machining, so it is cheaper and faster to produce.
Still, with all of that said, a Performance Center gun is a sweet piece. Enjoy.
The one thing I will comment on is the unfluted cylinder. I know some people really like the look of it, but extra weight on the cylinder has disadvantages in a double action revolver. When you pull the double action trigger, your finger strength has to rotate the cylinder. The heavier the cylinder is, the more effort that takes. Compared to the weight of cocking the mainspring, the cylinder weight is a minor issue, but it still matters.
And then once the cylinder is moving, the cylinder stop has to stop it. When the cylinder is moving fast in rapid double action, there is significant impact on the cylinder stop, the notches in the cylinder, and on the frame where the cylinder stop protrudes. Over time, these are significant wear areas in a revolver, and the heavy cylinder of an N-frame is especially prone to peen all of these areas.
For slow shooting, and for moderate amounts of shooting, the unfluted cylinder will certainly be fine. But a fluted cylinder is always my preference. I also find it amusing that an unfluted cylinder is often included on a premium model, and costs more. Yet the unfluted cylinder has less machining, so it is cheaper and faster to produce.
Still, with all of that said, a Performance Center gun is a sweet piece. Enjoy.