Like Mac said, the ladder gets in the way of wearing a hat. Outside of that, it works well.You guys must both be using the battle sight instead of using the ladder sight. I have NO trouble using a 6 o'clock hold with either of my 1917s using the ladder sight adjusted properly. No extra tall front sight required.
My 1917 is zero'd for 200 yards using the battle site, cuz that's really the only distance I'll shoot it at (CMP Games Matches).