First year hunter here. Been out for four full days and a few evenings this season. Seeing multiple does every other time out, but so far no luck taking anything. I took a pass on a fawn the other day, only because I got greedy during the ~20 seconds that my crosshairs were steadied on it, deciding at that moment that I wanted more meat than that for my antlerless permit. Of course, I'm currently at 0lbs. If I could go back, I'd take it. Been making a lot of other rookie mistakes as well, but I've also been learning a lot for the future.
I just got in from an afternoon in the woods at a new location. The location is far from ideal, but is basically a small valley (~110 yards across) with a fairly open pine stand on one side, a very open elm/hickory stand and no understory across the bottom, and a really thick, early successional pine stand up the other side. My only approach is from the open pine stand side, which is also always upwind, and there is a heavily used bedding site high atop the other side of the valley. There are game trails at the bottom of the valley, one following the edge on each side. Because of this I've been wary of crossing the valley. Earlier in the year I cleared out a spot behind a blowdown at the top of the hill on the approach side. The cover on the other side of the valley is so thick that I would barely even be able to see anything walking along the other game trail, even with boniculars, let alone have a clean shot from the blowdown. I've had pictures of two does throughout the year along the game trail on the approach side of the valley, but during each 2-3 week period that I've left the camera out, I've only gotten pictures once or twice.
Today I decided to cross the valley and put the camera up on the other game trail, to see if that is the one they use more often. Of course, just as I stand up after securing the camera, I see one of the ladies silently bouding away about 50' from me. Immediately found the nearest tree and sat behind it. After about 20 minutes of silence, I hear the ladies making their way up the other side of the valley, right by my blowdown. I started slowly moving out of the cover so I could see across the valley and stopped at a spot where I could just barely see them, but only as moving brown blobs through the trees. Pulled up my rifle to look through the scope, and sure enough it was the two of them. I panned a little bit to the side of them and I could see a third, much larger brown blob moving. As this blob walked into a small opening in the trees, its head appeared and I could see antlers! I didn't get a great look, but I did clearly see two spikes on one side, which is I guess not too impressive, but I was really surprised at just how long they were. Kept trying to slowly move into a position where I could get a shot, but eventually I just pissed the buck off and he started snorting at me. His snort was significantly deeper than any I've ever heard before. I figured since he already knew I was there, I might as well snort back and hope he thinks I'm just another buck. We went back an forth about 10 times before he finally got bored and trotted off to catch up with his ladies.
I've seen plenty of deer throughout the years, but this was my first time ever seeing a buck. So. F***ing. Cool!
So my questions now are:
1) How long will a buck follow a pair of does like this? Has anyone seen him following them one day, then gone out again the next day and seen the buck still following the same does? I'm considering going out super early for an all day sit tomorrow.
2) If I sit on either side of the valley, I will only be able to see the game trail on that side of the valley. There is also a new, small blowdown at the bottom of the valley where I could see both sides, but I'm a little concerned about being able to stay still enough all day long. I really only move when things start to go numb from the cold or pressure points, but that happens pretty often to me (every ~30 mins or so). Would you pick a side and hope they pick that trail? Or would you sit in the middle and hope they don't see/smell you?
Thanks!
- J