I love Merrill hiking boots, completely waterproof but only ankle ( 6") boots. Often time, quick draining boots with the proper socks are much better than waterproof. Light moisture, shallow stream crossings, cool weather are perfect for my Merrells. However if you have deeper water issues, I really like the Rocky SV2 quick draining boots. I have several pair, wear them all the time (more than the Merrells) treated the suede with leather treatment. Absolutely my favorite boots, most comfortable ever and have incredible ankle support - plus they can be found for $109 online if you look. Remember with waterproof, your feet will sweat something terrible too - I haven't found any boots yet that are waterproof that actually breathe well. If you buy waterproof boots that aren't muck boots (all rubber) remember that you'll have to keep treating them - especially the seams.