Josh - thanks for the info. No disrespect intended by my "club" comment - in the shooting world there are loads of "clubs", but also people using "club" as the designation for a sales operation.
I noticed that the registration data for handgunclub.com appears to use an intermediary to keep the actual registrated owner private.
Some posts on the net mention that the registration info for handgunclub.com used to list the owner as Josh Manheimer of "J.C. Manheimer and Company" (
http://www.directmailcopy.com). Is this reference on the net accurate and, if so, are Josh Mitchell and Josh Manheimer the same or different people? While I don't want to jump to conclusions that they are one and the same, it is interesting to note that directmailcopy.com is registered to a Josh Manheimer of Norwich, VT, and that both handguclub.com and directmailcopy.com are registered by tucows. Although these consistencies do not prove a correlation between the two organizations, the statistical chances of two unrelated sites being registered by the same low market share registrar, and being located in the same low population state are not all that great.
I think the reason you got "beat up" is that the very first thing on your site seemed to be "Join and get something for free" rather than "we are selling a service you may consider to be of value." Some people react to the free stuff approach positively, whereas other realize that it's just not practical to run around giving out free stuff to everyone who subscribes, and sees this more as a gimick that an actual attempt to get useful testing accomplished. I suspect the reaction on this list would have been more positive if you had said something like "we also ask our members to test stuff from time time, but it's not realistically possible to get something for everyone, especially as the organization grows, so please think of this as an extra plus, rather than a primary reason you should join."
Josh Manheimer is the founder of the club. Two of his close friends were murdered in NH several years ago (two college professors....you probably remember). After that happened he began to think much more seriously about defending his home and family from intruders.
He's not really a "Gun Guy" so he searched the web trying to find basic handgun information that would help him decide what to purchase, how to carry, home defense tactics etc..
Although there are a lot of websites that have handgun content.....he didnt feel like he was finding the answers he was looking for. Coming from a marketing background....he decided to form the Handgun Club so that others in similar situations would have a place to go for information.
I met him in a gun shop in Waterbury where he was shopping for his third pistol.
At this point.....he has stepped back from the daily operations of the club and acts as a marketing advisor. Thats where I come in. They hired me 6 months ago to be the Director of Operations. They needed someone who has worked in the gun industry before and is an actual avid shooter to head things up.
The domains were purchased before I was hired so I don't really know a whole lot about how that was done. The Club was run out of Josh Manheimer;s house for the first year so I assume he just wanted to keep his location anonymous for security reasons. Believe it or not,.......there are some pretty vicious antigunners out there.
The website is a little gimmicky....thats another of the reasons I was hired....to find ways to make the club more palpable to shooters. We're working on that every day and testing new ways to bring members in.
I really appreciate the feedback. I'm not a marketing guy so a lot of this is brand new to me.
This is not an "xxxxx Of the month" club. We dont send out unsolicited products and charge you for them later. (I cant imagine the paperwork that I would have to deal with if we did.....I'm buried as it is).
I'm not aware of a "Handgun of the month club" (although if you looked in my safe you would guess that I belonged to one
This club is really about getting shooters together and sharing information. In our last newsletter, we published an excellent article from a member who was in Iraq and had the chance to test 4 pistols and ancillary gear in that environment. He wrote a heck of an article and submitted it to us.
Anyway....I've gone on long enough.
There are indeed two Josh's.
Mr. Manheimer lives in Norwich, I live in Stowe where our business office is.
If anyone is in the area and would like to stop by anytime....feel free to give me a call. (802) 253-8333.
Theres a range 10 miles away in Waterbury and I'm always willing to go make holes in paper.
BTW......congratulations on your 1000th post