Chris
NES Member
- Joined
- May 24, 2005
- Messages
- 13,486
- Likes
- 8,403
Lot of Rambos in here.
No kidding.
Dark, smoke, surprise, loud soundtrack, flashing screen, screaming, people moving, utter chaos, etc. etc.
The vast majority of people would be pretty much useless.
When I ran the IDPA at Riverside, I created a total surprise stage to see how people would react when they had no idea what was coming. It was just an exercise. It was conducted with good shooters and a controlled situation. And yet, when the 'surprise' was sprung, it was quite educational. Some delayed in reaction until the scenario would have been over unable to act. Some shot the innocent. And a few actually neutralized the threat.
Don't get me wrong, armed defenders might have made a real difference. But to think it would have been quick and painless is being exceptionally unrealistic.
During the Revolutionary War, there were many a militia that set up along the road back to Cambridge in ambush. Some of these set up too close, or with their backs to geographical features that put them between the marching columns and the flanking troops. They knew the enemy was coming, they had the element of surprise, but the overwhelming force of the British wiped out several such groups with ease.
My point is that regardless what you want to speculate as a Monday Quarterback, the reality is that without some exceptional luck, any defender in that theater would be at a great disadvantage.