Recommendations for Tactical / Home Defense 12 ga Shotgun Ammo?

I don't think I trust semi auto shotguns for defense. I'd rather have a savage pump (just saying this cheap brand is perfectly reliable while a non cheap semi auto may not be). But semi auto anything is gonna be a matter of knowing what ammo is good to go as far as running in it for starters.

Lol you need to just let go of fudd tropes. It's not rocket science to get a semi that works fine with most brands of 00 buck and slugs.
 
You can't dump 5 rounds in 2 seconds with a pump.

:oops: Maybe he can't, but many people can.

FF the following to the 3 minute mark where he shoots 4 rounds in 1.42 sec. Pump-gun

He's not THAT fast a shooter, and given his split times, a fifth round would have been a total of 1.76 or so.

I have a friend that only shoots skeet with a pump. When others witness how fast he can work that action, I joke "That is the nice thing about a pump gun, you don't have to wait for the gas to cycle your action." ;)
 
Lol you need to just let go of fudd tropes. It's not rocket science to get a semi that works fine with most brands of 00 buck and slugs.

I guess I've just seen a lot of garbage ones. Obviously hardcore clay & bird enthusiasts have reliable versions.
 
If you stay away from Turkish shotguns, your odds of a good semi auto go up exponentially.
Yet.... there's plenty of turkatrons that work just fine.

And yes.... a lot of them are junk or throwaways too.... but this ancient fudd bullshit about semis not being reliable is just retarded. It's grounded in the fagottry of the fudds buying a box ww valpak 1200fps birdshot and having it not work in the semi when the gun was never made for that shit to begin with. 🤣
 
I guess I've just seen a lot of garbage ones. Obviously hardcore clay & bird enthusiasts have reliable versions.

You don't have to be "hardcore" at all. The $700 Rem 1100 tactical I had eons ago would run any decent 00 buck or slugs that had moderate to higher levels of juice. Reliably.
 
As important as the load you are using is your defensive plan. If you sleep on a second story, just post up at the top of the stairs and then all your misses will be going into the basement and not a threat to any neighbors.

If you are hunting through the house for Pookey and Ray-Ray, you may wind up shooting them when your wife is in the background. This can be a good thing or a bad thing depending on the wife.
 
What clone do you run and is it reliable? I've been thinking of picking up a clone myself. A Stoeger M3000, made by Benelli/Beretta using cheap Turkish labor and copying their own more expensive M2.
Clone 'ish'? Not Turkish but not USMC issue.

EX2Vf0CX0AQhfTR


Benelli M1014 civvy version in midnight bronze. Not my pic but this is it-

650350117370__19323.1723500221.jpg
 
Bookmarking best shotgun ammo, thank you.
That KSG-12, that on the list in MA or no?
I was told Benelli, accept no substitute.
2000 rounds later, it's still the same gun.
I have a bunch of Fudd shotguns, need a tactical, just so I can look cool.
According to them (end of page) its legal in all 50 states
 
Just did a little searching.


From a previous post:

Somewhere, DJBradles had a good youtube or some other video explaining #4 buckshot. This is why I'm interested. Maybe in the TSUSA thread.
Found this:

Can't find the #4 buck video at the moment. Will look tonight or something. Most likely in the TS thread.
This might have been it:

Someone else said:
Yeah, I’m in MA but I don’t hunt. 4 buck is a good home defense round as it won’t over penetrate as much as 00 buck will. It’s still going through some walls, just not as many and it makes me feel a little better having some in the inventory.




 
Last edited:
I personally use Remington 2 3/4" with #4 buck. Delivered by my Ithaca 37.
#4 is great at shorter distances like inside your house or just outside your door. If the threat is further away than that, it is probably not a threat or i am grabbing a different firearm.
As for the Ithaca choice? It is what i have and it works. As for effectiveness in real life, i have no experience. Just patterning at the range and LARPing in my back yard.
 
In case you missed it in my post above:

 
That’s crazy. A full size silhouette? At 10 yards I wouldn’t expect bigger than 6” spread. What size was the spread, and what barrel? 18” with no choke?

This highlights a good point I didn’t make though, always pattern your shotgun with what you intend to use. If it doesn’t work for your needs, try a different load or different choke if you can use chokes.
Yeah, 10 yards, should all be center mass, but scattered unless something else is missing in this picture. Maybe a zero choke shotgun?
 
I want to say when we did the shotgun demonstration, it was around 20 yards when we got significant pellets off center mass. I want to say even at 15 we were putting every pellet somewhere on a target. I also seem to remember we ran full chokes though.
 
You only shoot when life is in immediate danger. Is that the time to rely of the weakest possible ammunition?
An ounce and a half of lead, propelled at 13-1500 feet per second, would drop a man in his tracks even if he was wearing a vest (no it wouldn’t penetrate). It’ll absolutely pulverize drywall but it won’t penetrate exterior walls. At home defense ranges, it’s not going to pattern much larger than a saucer. It’s a decent choice for home defense.
 
An ounce and a half of lead, propelled at 13-1500 feet per second, would drop a man in his tracks even if he was wearing a vest (no it wouldn’t penetrate). It’ll absolutely pulverize drywall but it won’t penetrate exterior walls. At home defense ranges, it’s not going to pattern much larger than a saucer. It’s a decent choice for home defense.
It has noting to do with the total weight of the load, it is the weight of the pellet. The lighter the pellet, the lower the penetration

Do more research
 
Last edited:
Keep in mind that even most less lethal rounds (beanbags, rubber buck, etc) tend to go through drywall. Your best bet to avoid shooting into rooms you don't want to shoot into is to put the whole payload into the bad guy (once again, Flitecontrol shines at this).

this is wisdom
 
Anyone have any experience with the shorty buckshot shells? Something like this



Just don't load more than 5+1 in a semi.
 
It has noting to do with the total weight of the load, it is the weight of the pellet. The lighter the pellet, the lower the penetration

Do more research
It most certainly is the weight of the load as well as the kinetic energy imparted into the target that will cause hydrostatic shock. Overpenetration is wasted energy. Again we’re talking about home defense distances.

“Do more research” was dismissive and indicates that your opinion is absolutely correct and there’s nothing else worth discussing from your perspective. I stand humbled in the face of such expertise.
 
It most certainly is the weight of the load as well as the kinetic energy imparted into the target that will cause hydrostatic shock. Overpenetration is wasted energy. Again we’re talking about home defense distances.

“Do more research” was dismissive and indicates that your opinion is absolutely correct and there’s nothing else worth discussing from your perspective. I stand humbled in the face of such expertise.
Do more research
 
It most certainly is the weight of the load as well as the kinetic energy imparted into the target that will cause hydrostatic shock.
Do more research. No, seriously, this is such a ridiculous statement... Hydrostatic shock from birdshot [rofl]
 


I roll my own 12 pellets of #1 Buck in high brass. You can do 9 pellets for a low recoil load.
Haven’t bothered with the shotgun though since moving out of town.
Rifle and handgun are what is kept in reach and ready to go.
 
It most certainly is the weight of the load as well as the kinetic energy imparted into the target that will cause hydrostatic shock. Overpenetration is wasted energy. Again we’re talking about home defense distances.

“Do more research” was dismissive and indicates that your opinion is absolutely correct and there’s nothing else worth discussing from your perspective. I stand humbled in the face of such expertise.

1. Unless you dumped wax in the load, you need to consider each shot separately, not their combined mass. Each pellet is separately hitting the target and needs to be separately calculated for penetration. Mass, velocity, and diameter/sectional density all need to be considered for each individual pellet.

2. Hydrostatic shock isn’t a thing. When bullets transfer energy into tissue, they do create temporary cavities as the tissue stretches. Whether any of that cavity does damage or becomes permanent depends on whether that particular tissue’s elastic limit has been exceeded. This limit can be lowered through lacerations caused by fragmentation. And the more energy transferred, the bigger the temporary cavity. But most tissues can take a lot of stretch.

Edit: words
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom